Within hours of the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School pro-lifers began assigning causal rootedness in the culture of abortion. I’ve heard several people, some of whom are pro-lifers, object to making a connection. So the question needs to be addressed. Given the highly charged political and moral dimensions of the abortion debate, those most directly involved would not be entirely wrong to suspect some of hijacking their traumatic loss and the monstrousness of the experience. “Emotional Vampires,” was the label given by one critic. Harsh words for sure, but accurate?
Analysis of a tragedy on such a scale requires a great deal of information about what shaped the mind of the murderer. Only then can one assign causality along a continuum from most proximal to most distal. In this case that may take several months, as the media cannot be trusted to report factually or accurately, as evidenced by their having gotten wrong everything but the number of victims.
Given what little we do know, there is no indication that Lanza had anything to do with the abortion industry, ever had anything to do with a girl having an abortion, or having had a sibling aborted. That relegates abortion to the distal end of causality.
The connection, therefore, has to do with the coarsening of the culture, of which abortion is just one of many factors. When we discuss the Culture of Death, we discuss all of those factors which lower regard for the value, the dignity of the individual human life:
Abortion
Contraception
In Vitro Fertilization
Cloning
Embryo-Destructive Research
Physician-Assisted Suicide
Ever-Broadening Criteria for Brain Death
Capital Punishment
Domestic Violence
Rape
Incest
Workplace Injustice
Discrimination
Murder/Killing as Entertainment in Movies and Video Games
And that’s the short list. One could itemize hundreds of social justice issues that contribute to the coarsening of sensibilities regarding the worth of a single human life. That said, there can be no doubt that a nation having killed 56 million babies in the womb, regarding it with a blithe, business-as-usual attitude has diminished the worth of the individual.
Those are 56 million choices. It is the choice of the mother, enshrined in law, that determines the humanity of the child of the womb. If the mother decides otherwise then murder isn’t murder, because it’s her choice. No sane or rational argument can ever make that acceptable, and the insane and unthinkable is now a part of the fabric of American life.
In other words, we have, “Defined deviancy down,” as the late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan put it.
In other words, we have a new norm for human worth. It isn’t intrinsic, but contingent.
Contingent on the belief and will of the mother.
Contingent on the belief and will of the state.
Contingent on the belief and will of the employer.
Contingent on the belief and will of the lab researcher.
Contingent on the need for spare body parts.
The error of contingency of human worth is a mistake that we just can’t seem to escape. In slavery, segregation, eugenic sterilization, ethnic internment camps, and abortion, all have been supported by majority opinions by the U.S. Supreme Court. In every case the culture of the day was coarsened by the injustice, which left its muddy footprints all over the American landscape.
All of that said, there is a time and a place for everything. We’ll have plenty of time to debate it all after the funerals. For now, we need to wait on law enforcement to give us the most proximal causes for this tragedy. That may take quite some time. Most importantly, we need to lift up this community in prayer and give them the physical and virtual space to grieve.
Join the Coming Home family here tonight for Day 4 of our Novena to Our Lady of Lourdes for Healing.
Coming Home 
With great prayerfulness, I noted that 3,020 innocents died last Friday — 20 of them mourned by the world at Sandy Hook, and 3,000 unremembered from the privacy of their mother’s wombs. Perhaps the hearts softened by this tragedy will realize the greater tragedy happening every day.
so agree Gerard..there is plenty of time for all o f that..now is the time to mourn and pray
Unfortunately, with 3.000 deaths per day (in the womb) it is always a day to mourn and pray. It is only a special time for mourning and praying if those 20 deaths are somehow more tragic or more important than the nameless 3,000.
Pro-life ideology reduces the definition of human life to mere biological existence, a kind of Agambian bare life. It’s birth at all costs, regardless of what the woman thinks, feels, has planned for her future. This, to me, is the epitome of the “coarsening of our culture” — the idea that we are somehow entitled to women’s bodies.
The gunman lived in his mother’s house into early adulthood. By all accounts she was devoted to her youngest son. And her shot her in the head while she was sleeping — a gruesome, twisted expression of entitlement, in my book.
CET- Did you bother to read the article, or are you just talking over it to be heard?
What part of intrinsic vs. contingent human dignity did you not get? Are you aware that the issue of human dignity is metaphysical (above the physical)? The pro-life movement sees all humans as being made in the image and likeness of God (i.e. rational beings with an everlasting spiritual essence as well as a biological body). This means that the pro-life movement sees the human person as an integrated biological, spiritual entity requiring the language of philosophy and theology in addition to biology to fully grasp the person and their dignity.
In reality, it is the pro-choice movement that only sees the biological dimension of the human being, which is why your side is uninterested in and unmoved by any arguments over intrinsic human dignity, and why you root human identity and status in an ever-shifting set of biological, developmental endpoints (i.e. It’s human when its brain can think, feel pain etc.).
Nice try, CET, but you are the one who takes a disintegrated, solely biological view of the human person.
Sandy Hook’s tragedy involved 26 people dying. THose people were already here. Geez, get with it. As for the 3000 abortions a day, do you go after the 3000 men who abandon their progeny or just the confused, abandoned women. You people really know how to appoint guilt. BTW, is it pro-life to let your wife die?
Elania,
\The 3,000 are here too. You just can’t hear them scream when they’re being murdered. We don’t go after the women here. We save the opprobrium for the doctors who lie to the women about the baby’s developmental status so that she won’t change her mind.
As for letting women die, that’s a fallacy. Read the papers, Elania, the only women dying are the ones being killed in abortion clinics. That’s your side’s reality.
Own it.